• Home
  • Agric
  • Sci & Tech
  • Health
  • Environment
  • Hausa News
  • More
    • Business/Banking & Finance
    • Politics/Elections
    • Entertainments & Sports
    • International
    • Investigation
    • Law & Human Rights
    • Africa
    • ACCOUNTABILITY/CORRUPTION
    • Hassan Gimba
    • Column
    • Prof. Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Prof. M.K. Othman
    • Defense/Security
    • Education
    • Energy/Electricity
    • Entertainment/Arts & Sports
    • Society and Lifestyle
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Health & Healthy Living
    • International News
    • Interviews
    • Investigation/Fact-Check
    • Judiciary/Legislature/Law & Human Rights
    • Oil & Gas/Mineral Resources
    • Press Freedom/Media/PR/Journalism
    • General News
    • Presidency
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Board Of Advisory
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ethics Policy
    • Teamwork And Collaboration Policy
    • Fact-Checking Policy
    • Advertising
  • Wire News
  • The Stories
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Kogi boat accident claims 20 lives
  • ABU gets ₦4bn special funding to expand medical training
  • Forecast report: Global shipping enters “new regulatory era,” DNV warns
  • Dangote Refinery: PENGASSAN, NNPC, others evade service of court order to halt strike
  • Stop importing solutions, – APWEN advises Nigerian govt
  • Gombe takes measures to avert farmers-herders clashes ahead of harvest
  • Dangote Refinery, PENGASSAN meet in NSA’s office behind closed doors
  • ECOWAS supports Plateau children, farmers with $82m
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
AsheNewsAsheNews
  • Home
  • Agric

    Gombe takes measures to avert farmers-herders clashes ahead of harvest

    September 30, 2025

    ECOWAS supports Plateau children, farmers with $82m

    September 30, 2025

    Argus Fertilizer Africa Awards to honour trailblazers in Agriculture

    September 30, 2025

    Farming with equality: How AKILIMO is helping women grow, By Thompson Ogunsanmi

    September 29, 2025

    Science meets strategy: Communicating research for ROI, By Dr Aremu Fakunle

    September 29, 2025
  • Sci & Tech

    Stop importing solutions, – APWEN advises Nigerian govt

    September 30, 2025

    FG plans nationwide broadband expansion, says Salis

    September 30, 2025

    Video game giant EA to be taken private in $55bn sale

    September 29, 2025

    KEBRAM empowers 500 Katsina youth with python and cybersecurity skills

    September 29, 2025

    Commercializing research: Pathways and challenges for Nigeria and emerging economies, By Dr. Aremu Fakunle

    September 27, 2025
  • Health

    ABU gets ₦4bn special funding to expand medical training

    September 30, 2025

    Cardiologist urges stronger primary care to fight heart disease

    September 30, 2025

    PCN battles unsafe medicines, shuts illegal shops

    September 29, 2025

    NDLEA, RichyGold use football to tackle youth drug abuse

    September 29, 2025

    Kano hospitals hail NHIA reforms for saving lives, costs

    September 29, 2025
  • Environment

    Kogi boat accident claims 20 lives

    September 30, 2025

    Forecast report: Global shipping enters “new regulatory era,” DNV warns

    September 30, 2025

    Pregnant woman shot in Niger mining clash

    September 30, 2025

    Nigeria supports sanitation agenda at AMCOW summit

    September 30, 2025

    Jigawa govt approves N575m dyke project to mitigate flooding

    September 30, 2025
  • Hausa News

    Anti-quackery task force seals 4 fake hospitals in Rivers

    August 29, 2025

    [BIDIYO] Yadda na lashe gasa ta duniya a fannin Ingilishi – Rukayya ‘yar shekara 17

    August 6, 2025

    A Saka Baki, A Sasanta Saɓani Tsakanin ‘Yanjarida Da Liman, Daga Muhammad Sajo

    May 21, 2025

    Dan majalisa ya raba kayan miliyoyi a Funtuwa da Dandume

    March 18, 2025

    [VIDIYO] Fassarar mafalki akan aikin Hajji

    January 6, 2025
  • More
    1. Business/Banking & Finance
    2. Politics/Elections
    3. Entertainments & Sports
    4. International
    5. Investigation
    6. Law & Human Rights
    7. Africa
    8. ACCOUNTABILITY/CORRUPTION
    9. Hassan Gimba
    10. Column
    11. Prof. Jibrin Ibrahim
    12. Prof. M.K. Othman
    13. Defense/Security
    14. Education
    15. Energy/Electricity
    16. Entertainment/Arts & Sports
    17. Society and Lifestyle
    18. Food & Agriculture
    19. Health & Healthy Living
    20. International News
    21. Interviews
    22. Investigation/Fact-Check
    23. Judiciary/Legislature/Law & Human Rights
    24. Oil & Gas/Mineral Resources
    25. Press Freedom/Media/PR/Journalism
    26. General News
    27. Presidency
    Featured
    Recent

    Kogi boat accident claims 20 lives

    September 30, 2025

    ABU gets ₦4bn special funding to expand medical training

    September 30, 2025

    Forecast report: Global shipping enters “new regulatory era,” DNV warns

    September 30, 2025
  • About Us
    1. Contact Us
    2. Board Of Advisory
    3. Privacy Policy
    4. Ethics Policy
    5. Teamwork And Collaboration Policy
    6. Fact-Checking Policy
    7. Advertising
    Featured
    Recent

    Kogi boat accident claims 20 lives

    September 30, 2025

    ABU gets ₦4bn special funding to expand medical training

    September 30, 2025

    Forecast report: Global shipping enters “new regulatory era,” DNV warns

    September 30, 2025
  • Wire News
  • The Stories
AsheNewsAsheNews
Home»Viewpoint»VIEWPOINT: Does Anyone Deserve Immunity In Nigeria? By Prof Tonnie Iredia
Viewpoint

VIEWPOINT: Does Anyone Deserve Immunity In Nigeria? By Prof Tonnie Iredia

EditorBy EditorApril 10, 2022No Comments7 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

In 2007, the Nigerian judiciary turned down a request by the Federal Government to declare the office of Vice President Atiku Abubakar vacant on account of his defection from the then ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) to the Action Congress (AC). The decision was premised on Section 308 of the Nigerian Constitution which protects a sitting President and his Vice as well as State Governors and their deputies from being prosecuted in court while in office. Atiku’s case therefore helped to underscore the inviolability of the immunity clause. However, conscious of some likely negative effects, such as abuses by political office-holders, Umaru Yar’Adua, who became President a few months later, sought to expunge it from the Constitution. Yar’Adua pointedly argued during the launch of his anti-corruption campaign that nobody in Nigeria deserved “the right to be protected by law when looting public funds.”

The suggestion was well received in many quarters, especially by those who wondered which party manifesto a Defector-Vice President would execute while in a ‘limbo-office.’ Interestingly, the Action Congress reputed to consist of progressives opposed the proposal on political grounds thereby making it more difficult for possible negative fall-outs from Section 308 to be resolved. According to the then Publicity Secretary of the party, Alhaji Lai Mohammed, it was not the immunity clause that was protecting looters but the lack of political will by government to tackle corruption. The immunity clause survived, not because many were persuaded by the reasoning in Atiku’s case, but more because the attempt to sack Atiku was seen as political and not on account of corruption. In addition, Nigerians had assumed that any ill-gotten wealth garnered by corrupt leaders would be legally retrieved later while those found guilty of corrupt practices would be severely penalized.

This assumption has since been disproved especially after a former party chieftain declared that those who defect to the ruling party would have their sins forgiven. Perhaps, no one imagined that the immunity clause which was genuinely inserted in the Constitution to dissuade anyone from distracting the executive arm would be exploited by the same beneficiaries to commit mischief. The logical reasoning was that as a developing society challenged by infrastructural deficiencies, leaders in the executive arm would have so much to do about development to have spare time to be engrossed in politics. In truth however, many Nigerian politicians are prepared to hide under constitutional protection and technicalities to engage in unwholesome political and electoral mal-practices. It is now obvious in retrospect that office holders who enjoy immunity are able to use the privilege negatively for personal gains which was not the purpose of the provision.

This over-pampering of executives who are not required to reciprocate the goodwill accorded them ought to be reviewed. For example, whereas the constitution stops anyone from instituting legal cases against leaders in the executive arm, the same constitution failed to also bar such leaders, while in office, from initiating same against members of the public. So, they can sue but cannot be sued! They are also free to engage in political immorality which they quickly defend using the instrumentality of the immunity clause. Even the legal injunction that executives should not be engaged in other assignments except governance has not materialized. The first problem came from a new arrangement in which candidates elected at elections suddenly became designated by their parties as national leaders in the case of President or state leader in the case of governors. The main result of this designation and consequent preoccupation with party matters is that the executives have been diverted from spending ample time on governance issues as if they were elected by the entire electorate to run one political party or the other.

President Muhammadu Buhari as the national leader of the ruling APC has had to take charge of the party at different times. At a point he, had to arrange for a caretaker management when the party’s chairman was removed while he stepped in again recently to stop the party’s national convention from derailing. Governors Mai Mala Buni of Yobe, Abubakar Bello of Niger and Gboyega Oyetola of Osun had to virtually run the national working committee of their party for almost two years thereby relegating the tedious but substantive task of state executives. While many state governors are now more seen in Abuja than their state capitals dealing with one party issue or another, many have in the last one year traversed the length and breadth of the country on party assignments well ahead of the official time for electioneering. As a result, the original time for governance has been heavily appropriated while expanding the time for electioneering. Yet, the constitution, in anticipation of the numerous projects of development that have to be executed for the benefit of the masses barred everyone from distracting executives.

In the midst of these self/party imposed distractions, some governors are counselled that to be reelected or elevated to higher positions, they have to defect to another party. They hurriedly implement such arrangements ignoring the fact that their current positions were attained through the sponsorship of another political party. If legally challenged, they are able to plead Section 308 of the Constitution. What bothers many about this trend is that it is only the arguments of senior lawyers copiously quoting the Supreme Court that the people hear. No one considers that some die-hard actors would soon design extra-judicial arrangements to protect their votes from being transferred to another party. In other words, the injustice of defection which converts winners to losers by transferring the votes obtained at elections may soon generate political violence leading to another inexplicable insecurity. To confirm that there is no remorse about the approach, even legislators that the Constitution says should lose their seats upon defection are left untouched. What then is the purpose of voting, if the wishes of the people can be recklessly reversed?

The expectation that somewhere along the line, judicial activism would decisively put a halt to the vicious attack on the spirit of the Constitution is daily fading. At the same time, the justification for defection is becoming more bizarre by the day. The other day, one governor who was defending his defection from one party to another said on national television that he moved to avoid a fellow governor whom he described as a bully. He neither explained the venue of the alleged bullying nor how a governor in another state can stop him from working in his own state. What he inadvertently confirmed was that he loathes how the so-called unnamed bully operates during party meetings. But why should a governor, an otherwise statesman, be occupied with party matters? When the court declined to remove him from office, he publicly celebrated “victory” whereas what happened was that the court couldn’t find an approved punishment for his unwholesome conduct.

Except the country finds a way of reversing the trend, defectors would increase shortly thereby retarding national growth and development. So far, the way the cases in court challenging the politicization of governance are being handled suggests that the reprehensible conduct will not be addressed soon as all eyes are turned towards only the letters of the law. With the fast approaching primary election for which everyone is already in the mood for campaigns not much can be done in the area of pushing for an amendment to Section 308 of the Constitution. The direction to look towards in the circumstance is for our Supreme Court to help shape our public policy by using its powers of interpretation to positively expand the provisions of the section in such a way that the genuine intention of the drafters of our Constitution is attained. For example, considering that the judiciary has said that votes scored at an election belong to political parties, the executives wishing to defect should be allowed to do so but without taking away votes which still belong to their erstwhile parties.

Atiku Abubakar Immunity Nigerian constitution politics Prof Tonnie Iredia Ummaru Yar'Adua
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
Editor
  • Website

Related Posts

Crisis hits Sokoto ADC as members reject Isiyaku

September 21, 2025

[VIEWPOINT] Dangote and his two wives, By Funke Egbemode

September 19, 2025

Why APC’s new wave of lies, bigotry and daily propaganda against GRV keeps failing

September 17, 2025

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Kogi boat accident claims 20 lives

September 30, 2025

ABU gets ₦4bn special funding to expand medical training

September 30, 2025

Forecast report: Global shipping enters “new regulatory era,” DNV warns

September 30, 2025

Dangote Refinery: PENGASSAN, NNPC, others evade service of court order to halt strike

September 30, 2025
About Us
About Us

ASHENEWS (AsheNewsDaily.com), published by PenPlus Online Media Publishers, is an independent online newspaper. We report development news, especially on Agriculture, Science, Health and Environment as they affect the under-reported rural and urban poor.

We also conduct investigations, especially in the areas of ASHE, as well as other general interests, including corruption, human rights, illicit financial flows, and politics.

Contact Info:
  • 1st floor, Dogon Daji House, No. 5, Maiduguri Road, Sokoto
  • +234(0)7031140009
  • ashenewsdaily@gmail.com
Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
© 2025 All Rights Reserved. ASHENEWS Daily Designed & Managed By DeedsTech

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.