• Home
  • Agric
  • Sci & Tech
  • Health
  • Environment
  • Hausa News
  • More
    • Business/Banking & Finance
    • POLITICS
    • Entertainments & Sports
    • International
    • Investigation
    • Law & Human Rights
    • Africa
    • ACCOUNTABILITY/CORRUPTION
    • Hassan Gimba
    • Column
    • Prof. Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Prof. M.K. Othman
    • Defense/Security
    • Education
    • Energy/Electricity
    • Entertainment/Arts & Sports
    • Society and Lifestyle
    • Food & Agriculture
    • Health & Healthy Living
    • International News
    • Interviews
    • Investigation/Fact-Check
    • LAW & HUMAN RIGHTS
    • Oil & Gas/Mineral Resources
    • PRESS FREEDOM/JOURNALISM/PR
    • General News
    • Presidency
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Board Of Advisory
    • Privacy Policy
    • Ethics Policy
    • Teamwork And Collaboration Policy
    • Fact-Checking Policy
    • Advertising
  • Media OutReach Newswire
    • Wire News
  • The Stories
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • WHO lauds Nigeria for using health data to reach missed children
  • NLNG, NCDMB commit N12.78bn to research in six universities
  • COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels
  • NACCIMA, NITDA seek N3bn investment in Nigeria’s digital innovation
  • Naira weakens to N1,353.50 as dollar rate climbs further in November
  • Amnesty urges oil firms to fund Niger Delta environmental cleanup
  • UNHCR: 66,000 Nigerians flee insecurity into Niger, Benin
  • Nigeria needs digital investment to reach $1tn economy, NACCIMA says
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
AsheNewsAsheNews
  • Home
  • Agric

    NAPRI revives research-farmer linkage workshop

    November 10, 2026

    PIND urges collaboration to improve farmers’ access to quality seeds

    November 10, 2026

    AGROW pushes to strengthen agricultural value chains

    November 10, 2026

    Gombe engages stakeholders to avert farmer-herder clashes

    November 9, 2026

    FarmerMoni offers N300,000 loans to Niger farmers

    November 8, 2026
  • Sci & Tech

    NACCIMA, NITDA seek N3bn investment in Nigeria’s digital innovation

    November 11, 2026

    Nigeria needs digital investment to reach $1tn economy, NACCIMA says

    November 11, 2026

    CBN digitalises fiscal survey across 36 states, FCT and 774 LGAs

    November 10, 2026

    NAPTIP records 1,508 trafficking cases in 15 months

    November 10, 2026

    ISSAN: Build cybersecurity capacity as digital use grows

    November 10, 2026
  • Health

    WHO lauds Nigeria for using health data to reach missed children

    November 11, 2026

    Nigeria records no new Ebola cases in 21 days

    November 11, 2026

    NAFDAC urges vigilance against fake drugs

    November 11, 2026

    WHO unites 240 organisations to build trust in science

    November 10, 2026

    Adamawa reports 34 diphtheria deaths since January

    November 10, 2026
  • Environment

    COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels

    November 11, 2026

    Amnesty urges oil firms to fund Niger Delta environmental cleanup

    November 11, 2026

    NAHCON, Saudi Arabia sign 2027 Hajj agreement

    November 11, 2026

    Govt steps up push to end open defecation

    November 10, 2026

    Kogi begins 37km Idah–Ibaji road project

    November 10, 2026
  • Hausa News

    UNA signs MoU to launch air Bissau in Guinea-Bissau

    June 15, 2026

    Otti plans 250-room 5-star hotel in Umuahia

    April 11, 2026

    Anti-quackery task force seals 4 fake hospitals in Rivers

    August 29, 2025

    [BIDIYO] Yadda na lashe gasa ta duniya a fannin Ingilishi – Rukayya ‘yar shekara 17

    August 6, 2025

    A Saka Baki, A Sasanta Saɓani Tsakanin ‘Yanjarida Da Liman, Daga Muhammad Sajo

    May 21, 2025
  • More
    1. Business/Banking & Finance
    2. POLITICS
    3. Entertainments & Sports
    4. International
    5. Investigation
    6. Law & Human Rights
    7. Africa
    8. ACCOUNTABILITY/CORRUPTION
    9. Hassan Gimba
    10. Column
    11. Prof. Jibrin Ibrahim
    12. Prof. M.K. Othman
    13. Defense/Security
    14. Education
    15. Energy/Electricity
    16. Entertainment/Arts & Sports
    17. Society and Lifestyle
    18. Food & Agriculture
    19. Health & Healthy Living
    20. International News
    21. Interviews
    22. Investigation/Fact-Check
    23. LAW & HUMAN RIGHTS
    24. Oil & Gas/Mineral Resources
    25. PRESS FREEDOM/JOURNALISM/PR
    26. General News
    27. Presidency
    Featured
    Recent

    WHO lauds Nigeria for using health data to reach missed children

    November 11, 2026

    NLNG, NCDMB commit N12.78bn to research in six universities

    November 11, 2026

    COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels

    November 11, 2026
  • About Us
    1. Contact Us
    2. Board Of Advisory
    3. Privacy Policy
    4. Ethics Policy
    5. Teamwork And Collaboration Policy
    6. Fact-Checking Policy
    7. Advertising
    Featured
    Recent

    WHO lauds Nigeria for using health data to reach missed children

    November 11, 2026

    NLNG, NCDMB commit N12.78bn to research in six universities

    November 11, 2026

    COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels

    November 11, 2026
  • Media OutReach Newswire
    • Wire News
  • The Stories
AsheNewsAsheNews
Home»Environment/Climate Change»GMO safety debate is over, By Mark Lynas
Environment/Climate Change

GMO safety debate is over, By Mark Lynas

Abdallah el-KurebeBy Abdallah el-KurebeNovember 16, 2019No Comments6 Mins Read
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The GMO debate is over again. Last week, the prestigious National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine issued what is probably the most far-reaching report ever produced by the scientific community on genetically engineered food and crops. The conclusion was unambiguous: Having examined hundreds of scientific papers written on the subject, sat through hours of live testimony from activists and considered hundreds more comments from the general public, the scientists wrote that they “found no substantiated evidence that foods from GE crops were less safe than foods from non-GE crops.”

The National Academies process was both impressively inclusive and explicitly consensual. As noted in the preface to their report, the scientists “took all of the comments” however ludicrous “as constructive challenges” and considered them carefully. Thus the expert committee patiently gave yogic flyer-turned-anti-GMO activist Jeffrey Smith a generous 20-minute slot within which to make his customary assertion that genetically engineered foods cause just about every imaginable modern ailment. Greenpeace also offered invited testimony. So did Giles-Eric Seralini, the French professor who suffered the ultimate scientific indignity of having his paper claiming rats fed GMOs suffered tumors retracted in 2013.

Each of their claims was examined in turn. Do GE foods cause cancer? No patterns of changing cancer incidence over time are “generally similar” between the US, where GMO foods are ubiquitous, and the United Kingdom, where they are virtually unknown. How about kidney disease? US rates have barely budged over a quarter century. Obesity or diabetes? There is “no published evidence to support the hypothesis” of a link between them and GE foods. Celiac disease? “No major difference” between the US and UK again. Allergies? “The committee did not find a relationship between consumption of GE foods and the increase in prevalence of food allergies.” Autism? Again, evidence comparing the US and UK “does not support the hypothesis of a link.”

In a rational world, everyone previously fearful about the health effects of GMOs would read the report, breathe a huge sigh of relief and start looking for more evidence-based explanations for worrying trends in health issues like diabetes, autism and food allergies. But psychological associations developed over many years are difficult to break. A Pew Center poll in 2015 found only 37 percent of the public thought GE foods were safe, as compared to 88 percent of scientists, a greater gap than on any other issue of scientific controversy, including climate change, evolution and childhood vaccinations. These entrenched attitudes are not about to disappear especially since they are continually reinforced by a vocal and well-funded anti-GMO lobby.

There is also political path dependence. Vermont’s GMO labeling law, scheduled to throw US food manufacturers and retailers into chaos when it comes into force on July 1, is predicated on the explicit assumption that GE foods may be unsafe. “There is a lack of consensus regarding the validity of the research and science surrounding the safety of genetically engineered foods,” Vermont’s Act states in its preamble. Indeed, such foods “potentially pose risks to health [and] safety. Will Vermont’s legislature reconsider its Act now that it stands so clearly on the wrong side of a rock-solid scientific consensus? Of course not.

The National Academies report should make particularly uncomfortable reading for the environmental movement, many of whose leading member groups now exhibit all the hallmarks of full-scale science denialism on the issue. A spokeswoman from Friends of the Earth dismissed the report as “deceptive” before she had even read it. The group’s website claims that “numerous studies” show GE foods can pose “serious risks” to human health. Another environmentalist group, Food and Water Watch, issued a pre-publication rebuttal that conspiratorially accused the National Academies of having undisclosed links with Monsanto, before reasserting its view that “there is no consensus, and there remains a very vigorous debate among scientists… about the safety and merits of this technology.”

But despite these shrill denials, the truth is that there is no more of a debate on the safety of GE crops than on reality of climate change, the scientific consensus on which all these same green groups aggressively defend. And the irony goes deeper: many of the strategies now being employed to demonize GMOs come straight out of the climate denialist playbook. There’s the same promotion of false ‘no consensus’ statements by groups of self-appointed experts. Why, more than 300 “scientists and legal experts” signed a ‘no consensus on GMO safety’ statement last year, Greenpeace reminds us. That sounds like a lot, until you compare it with the 30,000 “American scientists” who have supposedly signed a petition claiming that there is “no convincing scientific evidence” linking CO2 with climate change, which Greenpeace (rightly in my view) ignores.

There’s also a worrying trend towards the harassment of bona fide scientists. Just as senior Republicans have shamefully targeted climate experts with politically-motivated subpoenas, so an anti-GMO group called US Right to Know has slapped dozens of geneticists and molecular biologists working at public universities with repeated Freedom of Information Act requests demanding access to thousands of their private emails. In some cases, scientists have as a result of subsequent campaigns received death threats, and had their laboratory and home addresses circulated menacingly on social media.

There is still plenty of room for genuine dissent moreover. The National Academies report is zealous in pointing out some of the experienced difficulties and drawbacks of GMOs. The overuse of GE crops has indeed led to the evolution of resistance, both in weeds and insects, it finds. Also, industry domination of the technology might restrict access of small farmers in poorer countries to improved seeds. And mandatory GMO labelling might well be a good way to raise public trust in a more transparent food system.

But these real areas of debate do not include GMO safety. That issue has now been definitively put to bed. So let’s be clear once again: the safety debate is over. If you vaccinate your kids and believe that climate change is real, you need to stop being scared of genetically modified foods.

Mark Lynas is a writer and campaigner on climate change and a visiting fellow at the Cornell Alliance for Science

Biotechnology GMO Mark Lynas
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email
Abdallah el-Kurebe
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Related Posts

COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels

November 11, 2026

NACCIMA, NITDA seek N3bn investment in Nigeria’s digital innovation

November 11, 2026

Amnesty urges oil firms to fund Niger Delta environmental cleanup

November 11, 2026

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

WHO lauds Nigeria for using health data to reach missed children

November 11, 2026

NLNG, NCDMB commit N12.78bn to research in six universities

November 11, 2026

COP31: UN chief urges faster shift away from fossil fuels

November 11, 2026

NACCIMA, NITDA seek N3bn investment in Nigeria’s digital innovation

November 11, 2026
About Us
About Us

ASHENEWS (AsheNewsDaily.com), published by PenPlus Online Media Publishers, is an independent online newspaper. We report development news, especially on Agriculture, Science, Health and Environment as they affect the under-reported rural and urban poor.

We also conduct investigations, especially in the areas of ASHE, as well as other general interests, including corruption, human rights, illicit financial flows, and politics.

Contact Info:
  • 1st floor, Dogon Daji House, No. 5, Maiduguri Road, Sokoto
  • +234(0)7031140009
  • ashenewsdaily@gmail.com
Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
© 2026 All Rights Reserved. ASHENEWS Daily Designed & Managed By DeedsTech

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.